What an HR centre of excellence is
An HR centre of excellence (مركز التميز), abbreviated HR CoE and spelt “center of excellence” in American usage, is a small specialist team that owns the design of one area of human resources for the whole organisation. It sets the rules, the tools and the standards for that area, and it leaves the daily running of the area to others.
Each part of that definition carries a condition. It owns the design, which means that the rules it writes are the rules the organisation works by in that area, not suggestions offered alongside them. Its scope is the whole organisation, so one design serves every department instead of each department building a separate version. And it leaves the running to others: the people who apply the rules from one day to the next sit outside the centre.
What an HR centre of excellence owns and what it does not
The line that defines an HR centre of excellence is the separation between design and operation. Design means deciding how something is to be done: the structure, the rule, the method of measurement. Operation means doing it, case by case and cycle by cycle, according to that design.
A centre of excellence for pay shows where the line falls. It builds the grade structure and the rules for the salary review, but it does not process the monthly payroll. The grade structure and the review rules decide how pay is set and how it moves. The monthly payroll applies those decisions to each employee in each month, and that application is operational work.
A centre of excellence for learning shows the same line in another area. It decides what people are trained in and how the effect of that training is measured, but it does not schedule the sessions. Choosing the content and the measure is design; arranging the dates, the rooms and the attendees is operation.
When an HR centre of excellence absorbs operation, the distance from which it was designing disappears. A team that runs the payroll every month, or fills the training calendar every week, is drawn into the deadlines of that work, and the time and the vantage point that design requires are taken up by it. The centre then still exists in name, but what it does is operation.
Areas for which an HR centre of excellence can be set up
The areas below are those for which an HR centre of excellence can be set up, each with the design work that falls to it.
- Pay and benefits. The grade structure, job evaluation (تقييم الوظائف) and total rewards (المكافآت الشاملة).
- Learning and development. The framework of competencies and the development paths built on that framework.
- Recruitment. The selection tools and the standards they apply.
- Performance management. The appraisal cycle and the rules that govern it.
The test for choosing an area has two parts. An HR centre of excellence is set up for an area whose design is built again in every department and comes out different each time, and whose mastery needs knowledge that is not available in every department. The two conditions work together. Design that is built again and comes out different shows that the organisation is producing several answers to one question. Knowledge that is missing from the departments shows that those answers cannot be made consistent simply by asking the departments to agree, because the expertise needed to settle the question is not present in each of them.
An area whose design does not recur to that degree does not get a centre. Instead, time is set aside for it within a role that already exists. The work of design is still done, but it is carried as part of a post rather than by a separate team.
What makes an HR centre of excellence useful
- Closeness to reality. Its design is built from actual cases within the organisation, not from a general reference. A rule written from those cases is written for the situations in which it will be applied.
- Outputs that others use. A rule, a template or a tool that is ready to use, not a memo of recommendations. Because the centre does not run the area itself, its work reaches the organisation only through what others take up and apply. A rule or a tool that is ready can be applied as it stands, whereas a memo of recommendations still has to be turned into something usable by whoever receives it.
- A declared boundary. It separates what the centre decides from what remains the decision of the department concerned. Where the boundary is declared, a department knows which questions it takes to the centre and which it settles itself, and the centre knows where its design stops.
- Periodic review. A design that is not reviewed can turn into a constraint. The organisation changes while the rule stays as it was written, and the gap between the two widens with each cycle in which nobody returns to the rule.
The fault that hollows out an HR centre of excellence
The fault is a centre that designs what is not applied. One cause is that the centre does not see the effect of its design: it hands over the rule and does not follow what happened when the rule was applied. Since operation sits outside the centre, the evidence of whether a design works gathers in the departments that apply it, and unless the centre goes back for that evidence, the evidence does not reach the centre at all.
The centre can then go on producing new rules and tools while earlier ones lie unused, and nothing in the work of the centre shows it. A count of outputs keeps rising whether those outputs are applied or not.
The practical remedy is to measure an HR centre of excellence by how much of its output has actually been used, not by how much it has produced. That measure turns the centre towards the point of application. To know what has been used, the centre has to look at what happened when its rules reached the departments, which is the very step whose absence produced the fault.
How an HR centre of excellence differs from a shared services center
Both are central units, and the difference between them lies in the kind of work, not in where they sit. An HR shared services center (مركز الخدمات المشتركة) carries out work that recurs and has one answer. An HR centre of excellence designs work that recurs less and calls for more specialism.
The measures follow from that difference. A shared services center is measured by turnaround time and accuracy, because its work is the same answer given repeatedly, and what counts is that the answer is given on time and given correctly. An HR centre of excellence is measured by the quality of what it has built and by how much of that is used, because its work is a design built once and applied by others.
Combining the two in a single unit can end with operation prevailing, because operation has a deadline and design does not. A payroll that falls due on a fixed date, or a request that must be answered within a set time, takes precedence whenever it competes with a design task that has no date by which it must be finished. Cycle after cycle the design work is postponed, and what the unit does becomes operation.
This is an explanation of the concept, not legal advice.
A standalone Saudi HR system
One employee file holding the contract, the documents and their expiry dates, the attendance record, leave, salary and end-of-service entitlements. End-of-service, overtime and leave-balance calculations are built into the system.
A standalone system on its own subscription. The connection to Qoyod Accounting is now available.